With the new year fast approaching, many businesses are preparing to close their doors for a well-earned break over Christmas and New Year. Whether it’s because clients and suppliers are also closed, or simply because most of your team wants time off, a temporary shutdown can make good business sense.
But before you lock the doors, it’s important to understand the legal rules that apply when you direct employees to take leave during a shutdown. Getting it wrong can lead to underpayment claims, disputes and unhappy staff at the start of the year. The rules depend on what covers your employees: a modern award, an enterprise agreement, or neither.
Annual shutdowns and modern awards
If your employees are covered by a modern award, you can only direct them to take annual leave during a shutdown if the award allows it. Most awards include rules about how and when you can give that direction.
In May 2023, the Fair Work Commission replaced the shutdown clauses in 78 modern awards with a standard “model clause”. Common awards with this clause include the Clerks – Private Sector Award, General Retail Industry Award, Hospitality Industry (General) Award, Legal Services Award and Professional Employees Award.
Under the model clause, you must:
- Give at least 28 days’ written notice of the shutdown to affected employees. A shorter period can apply only if agreed with employees. Some awards require longer notice – for example, the Building and Construction General On-Site Award requires two months.
- Give notice to new starters engaged after the notice went out, as soon as reasonably practicable after they start.
- Make the direction in writing and ensure it is reasonable.
- Only direct employees to take leave they have actually accrued. The model clause no longer allows you to direct employees to take unpaid leave.
A few other points to remember:
- Public holidays are paid. Christmas Day, Boxing Day (Proclamation Day in SA) and New Year’s Day are not deducted from annual leave if they fall on a day the employee would normally work.
- A shutdown is not a stand down. A stand down only applies where employees can’t be usefully employed for reasons outside your control, such as equipment breakdown or a natural disaster. A planned holiday closure doesn’t qualify.
- Plan your timing. For a shutdown starting just before Christmas, your written notice should go out by late November at the latest – earlier if your award requires a longer notice period.
If your employees are covered by an enterprise agreement, check its terms – the agreement may set its own shutdown rules.
What if employees don’t have enough annual leave?
This is one of the most common shutdown questions – especially for newer employees. You can only direct an employee to take the annual leave they have accrued. For example, if your shutdown runs for two weeks and an employee has four days accrued, you can direct them to take those four days only.
For the rest of the shutdown, your options are:
- Agree to annual leave in advance. If the award allows it, you and the employee can agree in writing for them to take leave before it has accrued. Leave taken in advance must be counted against future accruals.
- Agree to unpaid leave. The employee can agree to take unpaid leave for the balance. This must be genuinely voluntary – you can’t direct it.
- Pay them as normal. You can direct the employee not to attend work and continue paying their usual wages.
- Offer them work. If there is meaningful work available during the shutdown, the employee could keep working.
- Get agreements in writing. Keep a signed record of any agreement for leave in advance or unpaid leave.
- Check the award’s advance-leave clause. Many awards set out how advance leave works and what happens if the employee leaves before it is accrued. Any deduction from final pay must be authorised under the award and in writing.
- Don’t pressure employees. Agreement obtained under pressure isn’t genuine agreement and may expose you to a claim.
- Other leave types still apply. If an employee is sick or has another type of paid leave during the shutdown, they’re not taken to be on annual leave for those days.
- Communicate early. Tell employees with low balances well ahead of time so they can plan their finances and choose the option that suits them.
What if my award doesn’t contain a shutdown provision?
If the award or enterprise agreement covering your employees has no shutdown rules, you can’t direct those employees to take annual leave during a shutdown.
Instead, annual leave can only be taken by agreement between you and each employee. In practice, that means you’ll need to:
- Ask each employee whether they agree to take annual leave over the shutdown period.
- Discuss alternatives with anyone who doesn’t agree – such as continuing to work, working remotely, or paid time off.
- Record each agreement in writing.
Directing leave where your award doesn’t allow it can amount to a breach of the award. If you’re unsure whether your award contains a shutdown clause, check the award on the Fair Work Ombudsman website or ask for advice before issuing any notices.
What if my employees aren’t covered by a modern award?
Some employees – often senior managers and those in certain professional roles – aren’t covered by an award or enterprise agreement. For these employees, the National Employment Standards in the Fair Work Act apply directly.
Under section 94(5) of the Fair Work Act, you can require award and agreement-free employees to take paid annual leave, but only if the requirement is reasonable. The Act specifically notes that a temporary business shutdown over Christmas and New Year may be reasonable.
Here’s what you need to do:
- Check the employment contract. It may contain its own clause about shutdowns or directing leave. Make sure you follow it and that it doesn’t conflict with the NES.
- Make sure the direction is reasonable. Consider the employee’s circumstances, the length of the shutdown and how much notice you give.
- Give written notice early. There’s no fixed notice period in the NES, but giving similar notice to award employees (at least 28 days) is good practice.
- Handle low leave balances by agreement. You can agree with the employee to take annual leave in advance, or unpaid leave. Otherwise, pay them as normal for days not covered by leave.
- Pay public holidays. Public holidays during the shutdown are paid and not deducted from annual leave.
- Confirm which modern award or enterprise agreement covers each employee.
- Check whether it contains a shutdown clause and what notice it requires.
- Confirm shutdown dates and send written notice (at least 28 days, or longer if required).
- Review each employee’s leave balance.
- Agree options in writing with employees who don’t have enough leave.
- Make sure public holidays are paid and not deducted from leave.
- Update your leave policy and employment contracts for future shutdowns.
How Explore Potential can help
Shutdown rules vary from award to award, and a misstep can be costly. At Explore Potential, we help businesses get it right – from confirming award coverage, to drafting shutdown notices and leave agreements, to updating your policies and contracts.
If you’re planning a holiday shutdown this year, get in touch with our team at
info@explorepotential.com.au. We’ll make sure you’re compliant, so you and your team can enjoy the break.
This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your business, contact Explore Potential.